The Ghost of British Colonialism: Why Diabetes Loves the Desi Body

Why do South Asians develop diabetes younger and leaner than the rest of the world? The answer stretches back to the British Raj and starvation adaptation caused by 24 major famines, finds Urmi Bhattacheryya.
At some point during a PhD stint in the US, I found myself living in a small white Rocky Mountain town – as far from the subcontinent as one could imagine. A colleague who was researching tech use among diabetics (asking patients things like, did they know how to use automated diabetes tools?) – professed that she was having trouble finding people to interview – people who were middle-aged to older, managing “sugar” on the daily. I wanted to help, so I asked, would she like to speak to my mother? An itemised list of uncles and aunts, perhaps? “Literally, anyone at all,” I laughed. Only half-jokingly, for that is the punchline of the desi life.
Diabetes is ubiquitous in India and South Asia, at large: a 2023 Lancet study records the highest numbers seen thus far: at least 101 million people in India (about 11 per cent of the adult population) are living with diabetes, and about 136 million (14 per cent of adults), with pre-diabetes. There are a myriad reasons to worry – not least of which is: if you’re pre-diabetic in India, the “conversion to diabetes… is very, very fast”: more than 60% of us with pre-diabetes will end up becoming diabetic in the next five years. In fact, if you framed that in a global context, a whopping one-fourth of the world’s diabetics lives in India, bestowing upon us the bilious moniker of the ‘diabetes capital of the world’. While China has the most diabetic adults in absolute numbers (approximately 140 to our 101), we’re done in by the rate: we’re becoming diabetic far quicker than our neighbours.
More and more, we’re talking about how diabetes morbidly spans and holds in a vice grip our kidneys, our hearts, our lives. More and more, we’re arguing origin stories — with many researchers pointing at the piece of the puzzle we’ve missed so far: colonial trauma and its domino effects, well into 2026. But how did we get here?
Why Diabetes Develops – and Why Indians Get it
Today, Type 2 diabetes (T2D) accounts for over 90% of cases, but what is it?
The “locked door” analogy might be a good way to explain what happens to a body with diabetes. Here’s what should happen: after eating — and during digestion — food is broken down into glucose, which raises our blood sugar levels. When the pancreas “senses” this, it automatically releases a hormone called insulin to help transmit this glucose to our cells. Basically, the cell doors are “locked” until insulin helps open them — helping, that is, until these cell doors stop recognising insulin, aka insulin resistance develops. Now, the pancreas begins to produce even more insulin to keep up, eventually tiring out. Consequently, insulin levels drop — and blood sugar skyrockets (since, theoretically, there’s nothing to help it along) causing diabetes.
So why does it have such a propensity for making a home in South Asian bodies?
Besides India, both Pakistan and Bangladesh are among the 7 most “diabetic countries” in the world — a risk that seems to bind an erstwhile-unpartitioned subcontinent. We now know that South Asians (here, meant to signify mainly Indians, Pakistanis, and Bangladeshis) have a tendency to store fat around the middle: this amounts to visceral fat developing around the organs, classically associated with diabetes risk. They also, on average, get diabetes much younger than their racial counterparts (at least 10 years younger than white Europeans, for instance).
The looming questions is: why us?
“I think the prevailing paradigm we have has used mostly white European data,” says Dr Alka Kanaya, Professor of Medicine, Epidemiology and Biostatistics at the University of California San Francisco, US. That data, she says, has confirmed one pathway of developing Type 2 and that’s insulin resistance: “You see that in most high-income countries where it’s about obesity or an obesogenic diet causing insulin resistance, where the pancreas has to combat that by secreting more and more insulin until it gets exhausted.”
But increasingly, Kanaya insists, there is data coming out of South Asian and East Asian countries and countries with those diasporas that show a different picture. “Along with insulin resistance, there is also an insulin secretion issue that is not as frequent in white populations. We’re born with fewer well-functioning pancreatic beta cells.” Potential reasons, her research argues, may be related to toxins, environmental reasons or epigenetic mutations, all of which might have caused us to fare worse than white Europeans. Diabetologist and Padma Shri Dr Viswanathan Mohan, head of Madras Diabetes Research Foundation, concurs; “For Indians, insulin deficiency (i.e. impaired beta cell function) is equally, if not, more important than insulin resistance — it is much more common in us compared to other populations.”
South Asians, then, might be developing T2D through two pathways — and it’s this latter (poorer beta cell function in the pancreas), she says, that is causing us to develop it earlier than other races. “That’s what we’re seeing in the very lean, non-obese Indian — where, their diabetes did not go through an obesity pathway.”
I chew on the alarming note in this statement, and scrabble to find more answers. What are these epigenetic mutations, and what could have incited them?
The Enduring Arm of the British Raj
A new hypothesis has been floating around — that we are the way we are because of “starvation adaptation… (due to) colonial-era famines”. In fact, a now-seminal 2022 study says: South Asians, currently living in more abundance than ever before (and certainly more than when they were colonised by the British), are in an “evolutionary mismatch” because their physiologies have adapted to starvation.
If you’ve ever wondered why we seem to have lower lean body mass (that’s the weight of a body minus the fat) than so many other races, or lower resting energy expenditure (aka, total calories burned by the body at rest) despite seeming to do at least equivalent work, then you could — in some measure — attribute it to our foremothers having starved, before. It is a bleak picture.
The study, and a book on the same subject (written by the same authors), asks us to think about the famines during the nearly 200-year-long British Raj. How could 31 major famines in our 190-year period of colonisation, compared to only 17 in the 2,000 years before colonialism, not cause some form of adaptation? Especially since these famines were, as the authors argue, “some of the worst in human history”?
I look through the public Instagram page for Dr Mubin Syed, lead author of Healing From Our History: How Colonial-Era Famines Led to A Modern South Asian Health Crisis, and South Asian health advocate, and it paints a picture. Bitter pills are doled out in easily-digestible form: plumes of soft bread and drippy ice cream make a point about high-fat/calorie diets for South Asian bodies vis-à-vis Caucasians’ — and how they cause us to march quicker towards diabetes. Grim, grainy shots of contorted bellies and starved faces reiterate the horrors of the terribly mismanaged Bengal famine of 1943 — commonly decried as “man-made”. Photos of Dr Syed, who is a physician specialising in endovascular therapy, lying in hospital, accompanied by captions of a heart attack at 52, offer glimpses into his motivations.
“I’d always thought of myself as reasonably health-conscious, so when it happened, I found myself asking: ‘Why are so many South Asians experiencing serious cardiovascular disease even when we don’t necessarily fit the traditional risk profile?’” he says of his beginnings into investigating South Asian health. What he saw was that, medicine and public health had rarely integrated our colonial history into conversations about metabolic disease, and he wanted to change that.
Indeed, there are strong examples of this elsewhere in the world. A 2016 study found that individuals exposed to the Great Chinese Famine (1959-61) as children had a significantly greater risk of developing T2D as adults. Such examples are also found among Irish and indigenous American populations, attributed to something called the “thrifty gene phenotype” — whereby individuals can efficiently store energy during famines (giving them a survival disadvantage) — but are trounced by that same “advantage” in the modern day. A strong uptick in diabetes after the Great Irish Famine (1845-52) and the Ukraine Famine (1932-33) has also been explained this way.
Why Decolonising (Diabetes) Matters
Late US historian Mike Davis argued against reading famine during British rule in India as an “accident”, claiming that “(Britain’s imperialist policies) were often the exact moral equivalents of bombs dropped from 18,000 feet”. Between just 1850 and 1899, for instance, India suffered 24 major famines — higher than any other 50-year-period in recorded history, resulting in millions of deaths. Weather anomalies like El Nino and British exacerbation, particularly the ’43 Bengal Famine that claimed at least 3 million lives (after food grains were shifted to war-torn Britain), were the final nail in the coffin.
If we now know that surviving just one famine doubles the risk of developing T2D in the next generation and more than doubles the risk of cardiovascular disease for that generation’s grandchildren — can you imagine what surviving 24 would do?
Today, in an increasingly polarised 2026, the conversation must marry intersecting fields of medicine, race, geopolitics.
Dr Amartya Sen previously argued that the inequality of food practices during British-era famines were due to the undemocratic practices of the Empire — a thought carried forward by Syed, Deek and Shaikh, all of whom point to how food grain availability per capita decreased dramatically — from 200kg in the year 1900 to 157kg before WWII… and further to 137kg by 1946. This is evidenced, writes journalist Madhushree Mukherjee, in then-British PM Winston Churchill’s wartime policy denying food supplies to Bengal for fear of a Japanese invasion, even as he wondered aloud “how Gandhi was still alive if the famine was so bad”.
Combine this with Britain’s “historical amnesia” (as writer-politician Shashi Tharoor dubs it) about atrocities of its past Empire and the chapter on colonial history that English school curricula still misses, and you’re looking at a web of severed links.
I ask why we haven’t talked of South Asian diabetic “anomalies” before – and, like Dr Kanaya, Dr Syed stresses the gap in research. Metabolic research has historically been conducted on European populations, not us. That, and the fact that India and South Asia have only recently experienced widespread economic growth and calorie availability explains why we’re only now seeing how bodies, adapted to scarcity, respond when there’s more food.
Sorry State
Today, we’re growing more (food grains) but eating less and less. Instead, what we are eating more of, are heavily/ ultra processed foods (UPFs) (think: your average “cold drink”, prepackaged chips and biscuits, palm-sized instant noodles, ready-to-cook batter, etc.) — all linked to our diabetes dilemma.
“It’s the perfect storm,” warns Dr Kanaya. “I mean, when you have all these disadvantages biologically – and then, you get access to these ultra-processed foods, can you imagine how dangerous that is? It’s hard because ultra-processed foods are cheap.”
There’s also our losing battle with air pollution, that Dr Mohan tells me is now “a new independent risk factor for T2D”. “Muscle mass is one of the body’s best defenses against insulin resistance,” Dr Syed tells me — which means resistance training would be a great counter — but sadly, less than 8% of the population in India does any form of exercise.
The blueprint to a non-T2D life (more weight training, less pollution, less processed foods) is simple; our historical x-rays are not – and that’s important. “The goal,” Dr Syed reminds me, “is not to reduce complex health patterns to one historical explanation, but to broaden the conversation.” To give us a fighting chance, I surmise?
For even as I write this, my 73-year-old diabetic, hypertensive mother wakes to rub the early morning off her dumbbells. She stands her small frame in place, presses them determinedly overhead. I watch hawk-eyed. For too many of us, the numbers are personal.
Urmi Bhattacheryya is an independent journalist in India, primarily reporting stories of sexual violence, and health and social justice. She is also the author of the book After I Was Raped – published by Pan Macmillan. Find her on X (Twitter) @Urmi_1990 and on Instagram @UrmiTellsStories.
ALSO ON GOYA